Alpha leadership isn't loud; it's ready for action
Leadership’s got this PR problem. Somewhere along the way, it became synonymous with being loud. Big presence. Big talk. Big energy.
The kind of leader who strides into a room, commands attention with the sheer volume of their voice, and is assumed to be the alpha simply because they fill the air.
But the thing is - alpha has never been about volume. It’s about presence. Calm. Precision. Knowing when to act and when to listen. Readiness, not restlessness.
Leadership is the whole musical scale
Here's where the metaphor gets richer: Leadership is like music. One note, played over and over, gets tiring. It grates on the ear. It’s the repetition of sameness. Predictable, monotonous, and dull.
But that same note? Placed strategically within a melody, it can be powerful. When paired with tension, release, harmony, or even dissonance, it becomes essential. It plays its role.
Music without contrast is flat. It needs light and dark, loud and soft, tension and resolution. The sharpness of a dissonant chord can be just as essential as the sweetness of a perfect one. It’s the range that makes it music.
Leadership is no different. It’s not about being the loudest instrument in the room - it’s about knowing when to turn the volume up, and when to let others take the lead. The true skill is having range. Knowing when to be loud and directive, and when to be quiet and receptive.
Navigating the leadership spectrum
It’s wild how we equate confidence with noise. The truth? Leadership lives across a spectrum.
I've seen leaders struggle because they think they have to be on ALL. THE. TIME. Loud, commanding, relentlessly present. But leadership lives across a spectrum:
Quiet to loud.
Micro-managing to macro-mentoring.
Collaborative to directive.
Strategic to intuitive.
The real skill is knowing how to move along those dimensions with intention. Translation: music > noise.
Some of the most effective leaders I’ve coached aren’t the ones who fill the air with words. They’re the ones who create space for others to fill. Their strength isn’t in how many words they say, but in how intentionally they use them.
We do leaders a disservice when we equate boldness with bravado. And when we label the measured, the thoughtful, the understated as somehow lesser because they don’t fit the archetype of what we think an alpha should be.
Leadership isn’t one note. It’s the entire damn scale. And the sooner we recognize that range, the better we can harness the brilliance of those who lead from places of calm, clarity, and quiet certainty.
Because when it comes down to it, alpha isn’t about how loud you are. It’s about how ready you are.
Dive deeper with these resources:
TED Talk: “The Power of Introverts” by Susan Cain: A brilliant breakdown of why quiet leadership is not just valid but powerful.
Book: Range: Why Generalists Triumph in a Specialized World by David Epstein: A fascinating exploration of how range, adaptability, and breadth of experience often outweigh expertise.
Podcast: The Tim Ferriss Show - Episode with Rick Rubin (Music Production & Creativity): Rick Rubin talks about how silence and patience are often the most powerful tools in creating something brilliant.
Article: “Why Leadership Is More Like Jazz Than a Symphony” by John Coleman: A compelling read about improvisation, collaboration, and adaptive leadership.
The bottom line here:
Leadership isn’t one note. It’s the entire damn scale. The real alpha energy? It’s about being calm, sure and ready to ~range~
My best, always,
Shar
---
Unsubscribe | Update your profile | 20 Bay Street, 11th floor, Toronto, ON M4J2N8